Yesterday, I was flipping television channels and I heard a woman say:
“Thank you Christopher Columbus for discovering America.”
And if you’ve been reading or you know me personally, you know that I have several problems with this statement.
- It is from a white dominant standpoint. It implies that “America” did not exist or have a history before a white man, Christopher Columbus, discovered it. It completely leaves out that fact that there was a rich native history in North America prior to Columbus’ “discovery.”
- By using the term “America” it puts the United States as more important than other countries in North, South, and Central America. It’s basically saying that the United States is greater than more than 15 other countries. No wonder other countries think that we are full of ourself.
- It completely leaves out the consequences of Columbus’ “discovery,” which was the start of the genocide of the
Native AmericansAmerican Indians. We all know that school textbooks never like to use the word genocide and American Indians in the same sentence. As a society, we have a hard time admitting our mistakes, especially grave ones.
We have to wonder why our government has sanctioned the celebration of this holiday. And before I go further, let me state that I’m not hating on Columbus. We can acknowledge some of his accomplishments, like surviving long voyages at sea (hint of sarcasm). But like every historical figure we have made a hero, we need to examine the positives and negatives of that person’s accomplishments.
We need to acknowledge that when we are “celebrating” Columbus Day every year, that we are doing so from a white dominant perspective.
So I want to share with you this video I that I found years ago. I think it sums up the point really well. It asks us to reconsider celebrating Columbus Day. And questions…
“Should we really be celebrating Columbus Day?”
**Note: As I shared, this video is a few years old. The website at the end of the video is no longer active. Also, Columbus Day was on a different date this year.








